Firefly III vs Actual Budget
Neither app charges anything, so choose Firefly III for a self-hosted double-entry web application and Actual Budget for local-first envelope budgeting with encrypted sync. Deployment differs: Firefly III runs on your own server via Docker as a web app; Actual Budget ships for web plus Windows, macOS and Linux, keeps the database on your device and offers managed hosting near $1.50/month on Fly.io. Method and extras: Actual Budget implements envelope (YNAB-style) budgeting, encrypts budget files end-to-end and supports shared access; Firefly III builds on double-entry records with piggy-bank goals, recurring transactions, auto-categorization rules and bank reconciliation. Both are open source and community-maintained without subscriptions.
Official websites: firefly-iii.org · actualbudget.org
Key differences
- Method: Firefly III tracks money on double-entry principles; Actual Budget implements envelope, YNAB-style budgeting
- Hosting: Firefly III is a self-hosted web app via Docker; Actual Budget is local-first with desktop builds and managed hosting near $1.50/month
- Sync: Actual Budget encrypts budget files end-to-end and lists shared access; Firefly III stays entirely on your own server with no ads or tracking
- Features: Firefly III adds piggy-bank goals, recurring transactions and bank reconciliation; Actual Budget adds offline mode
Comparison
| Criterion | | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | For free; hosted on the user's own server (Docker) | Completely free (open source); costs - only your own synchronization server hosting or managed hosting ~$1.50/month (Fly.io) |
| Platforms | Web | Web, Windows, macOS, Linux |
| Features | ||
| Shared features | ||
| Bank sync | yes | yes |
| Data storage | local | both |
| Device sync | yes | yes |
| E2E encryption | no | yes |
| Multi-user | no | shared |
| Status | Active | Active |
| Open source | Yes | Yes |
| Rating | Not enough public ratings | Not enough public ratings |
Who it fits
Self-hosters comfortable with Docker who want rule-based auto-categorization, recurring transactions and double-entry reports under full control fit Firefly III; envelope budgeters who want a local database, encrypted multi-device sync and a desktop app fit Actual Budget.
Pick Firefly III if: You can run Docker, want rule-based auto-categorization, piggy-bank goals and double-entry reporting on your own server.
Pick Actual Budget if: You prefer envelope budgeting on a local database with encrypted sync across desktop devices and a cheap managed option.
FAQ
Both are free and open source — what differs?
Deployment and method: Firefly III is a self-hosted personal finance manager (Docker on your own server) with double-entry books, budgets and piggy-bank goals. Actual Budget is local-first envelope budgeting — the database lives on your device, syncing through your own or managed hosting at about $1.50/month on Fly.io.
Which is easier to self-host?
Actual Budget — a managed option exists at roughly $1.50/month if you skip running a server. Firefly III always requires your own server or Docker host, though the software itself is free.
Which has bank reconciliation?
Both list bank reconciliation among their features. Neither automates bank feeds in their catalog records — imports and manual entry carry the data in.
See the full reviews: Firefly III and Actual Budget.