Expensify vs Shoeboxed

For scanning receipts yourself at little or no cost, Expensify is the fit; for hands-off paper handling, Shoeboxed, whose staff digitize what you mail in. Expensify's SmartScan is unlimited even on the free Submit plan for individuals, with Collect at $5 per member monthly and Control at $18 on annual billing, wrapped in report approval, ACH reimbursements, its corporate card, invoicing and bill pay. Shoeboxed instead sells flat tiers of $9, $29, $79 and $179 monthly: paper receipts travel in a prepaid Magic Envelope, get scanned and categorized by humans, and come back as IRS-ready reports for freelancers and small businesses. One more difference: Expensify publishes its source code and is open-source, while Shoeboxed is not.

Both apps are featured in the FinAppReview round-up: Best Receipt Scanner Apps 2026: Expensify .

Key differences

  • Scan labor: Shoeboxed's prepaid Magic Envelope outsources scanning and categorization to its own staff; Expensify's SmartScan does the reading inside its app
  • Free tier: Expensify's Submit is free for individuals with unlimited SmartScan; Shoeboxed is paid-only, with tiers from $9 to $179 monthly
  • Beyond scanning: Expensify adds report approval, ACH reimbursements, its corporate card, invoicing and bill pay; Shoeboxed adds auto-categorization, charts and IRS-ready output
  • Source code: Expensify publishes its source code and is open-source; Shoeboxed is not

Comparison

Criterion Expensify Shoeboxed
Pricing Submit - free plan for individuals (including unlimited SmartScan); Collect $5/member/month; Control — published pricing: $18/member/month on annual subscription ($36 pay-per-use), as low as $9/member/month with annual subscription + Expensify Card usage (up to 50% discount) Starter $9/month ($97/year); Pro $29/month ($297/year); Plus $79/month ($797/year); Paper Plus $179/month ($1997/year)
Platforms Web, iOS, Android Web, Android, iOS
Features
InvoicingSpend management
Auto-categorizationReports & charts
Shared features
Expense trackingReceipt scanningExpense reports
Bank sync yes no
Data storage cloud cloud
Device sync yes yes
E2E encryption — —
Multi-user enterprise shared
Status Active Active
Open source Yes No
Rating Not enough public ratings Not enough public ratings

Who it fits

Freelancers who want free unlimited SmartScan, and teams paying $5–$18 per member for approvals, reimbursements, cards and invoicing, fit Expensify. Freelancers and small businesses buried in paper receipts who want them mailed away and categorized by humans fit Shoeboxed.

Pick Expensify if: you want unlimited self-scanning on a free plan, with room to grow into approvals, reimbursements and corporate cards at $5–$18 per member.

Pick Shoeboxed if: you want to mail paper receipts in a prepaid envelope and receive human-categorized, IRS-ready expense reports without operating a scanner.

FAQ

Which is cheaper to start with?

Expensify: its Submit plan is free for individuals and includes unlimited SmartScan. Shoeboxed has no free tier — paid tiers begin at $9/month ($97/year) for Starter.

Does Shoeboxed scan receipts for me?

Yes — that is its specialty: paper goes out in the prepaid Magic Envelope and Shoeboxed's staff scan and categorize it, or you scan it yourself. Expensify's SmartScan reads receipts you photograph digitally; nobody handles your paper.

Is Expensify open source?

Yes — Expensify publishes its source code. Shoeboxed is a closed, subscription-based service.

See the full reviews: Expensify and Shoeboxed.

This comparison was compiled by the FinAppReview editorial team from public data; the order of participants expresses no preference and is not a ranking. See the about the project section for the methodology. Links to official websites are nofollow. Data is collected from public sources and may become outdated; verify prices and terms on official websites.